By AshleyKandestinMitchellGattuso S.E.N.C. Ordre des optométristes du Québec c. Coastal contacts inc., 2014 QCCS 5886 is a caseinvolving questions of exclusive professional practices, private internationallaw, the constitutional division of powers and consumer protection. In it,Justice Paul Mayer of the Superior Court ruled that the Loi sur l’optométrie (the “LSO”) and related professional legislationdoes not apply to out-of-province purveyors of prescription eyeglasses whentheir products are sold online to Quebec residents. L’Ordredes optométristes du Québec(the “Order”) sought a declaratory judgment against Coastal Contacts and anaffiliate stating that they contravene the Quebec professional legislation byselling prescription eyeglass lenses to buyers in Quebec without beingregistered optometrists with the Order. The defendants are headquartered inVancouver where their sales activities are subject to and in compliance withthe relevant provincial legislation. Among other importantfindings, Justice Mayer found the following: 1. Consumerprotection laws do not apply to the sale of eyeglasses or contact lenses inQuebec, as professionals are… Lire la suite
Auteur : Ashley Kandestin
When a Plaintiff is Exempt from Producing an Expert Report in a Professional Liability Suit
By Ashley KandestinMitchell Gattuso In a lawsuit pitting a patient against her plastic surgeon, the Superior Court outlines when an expert report is necessary in a medical malpractice suit. In Dubé c. Tardif, 2014 QCCS 5519, the plaintiff’s claim rests on the alleged cavalier manner in which the defendant communicated with the plaintiff’s insurance company regarding the plaintiff’s disability leave. The communication led the plaintiff’s employer to refuse benefits and to eventually terminate her employment. The defendant doctor brought a motion to dismiss the suit based on the plaintiff’s failure to produce an expert report establishing the defendant’s departure from the reasonable conduct of another professional placed in the same circumstances. The Honourable Justice Fournier dismissed the motion, on the basis that the plaintiff need not prove this specific fault with an expert’s opinion. Reminding us of the rule established by the Court of Appeal in Leduc c. Soccio, 2007… Lire la suite
The Difficulty in Appealing Interlocutory Decisions Rendered by the Quebec Human Rights Tribunal
By Ashley KandestinZSA Recrutement juridique In January 2014, the Quebec Human Rights Tribunal dismissed a declinatory motion, the subject of which was its absence of jurisdiction. The unsuccessful defendant took the decision before the Court of Appeal, asking for permission for leave under section 132 of the Quebec Charter of Human Rights, which grants an immediate right of appeal on permission of final judgments. The question before the Court in For-Net Montréal inc. c. Chergui, 2014 QCCA 1508 was whether or not the Tribunal’s judgment dismissing the declinatory exception and allowing the case to proceed was qualified as a final or an interlocutory judgment. The Court first reminds us of the rule that the Tribunal’s interlocutory judgments are never appealable, the legislator having ensured that “l’accès à la Cour au stade de l’interlocutoire n’est pas souhaité par le législateur qui préfère laisser porter le débat devant le Tribunal au fond,… Lire la suite
The Court of Appeal is Divided on the Principles to Apply When Determining Punitive Damages in the Context of an Employment Contract
By Ashley KlandestinZSA Recrutement Juridique In IBM Canada ltée v. D.C., 2014 QCCA 1320, the Court of Appeal weighed in on the awards granted by the Superior Court for the wrongful dismissal of a former IBM employee. The trial judge, Justice Borenstein, granted $300 000 in punitive damages, which formed part of the debate before the Court of Appeal. The court’s decision, composed of three written reasons, is split as to the principles governing punitive damages for wrongful dismissals in Quebec. In his reasons, Justice Pelletier dismisses the punitive damages award completely while Justices St-Pierre and Gagnon were of the opinion that the award was well founded but for the amount, which they reduced to $25 000. At paragraph 156 of the decision, Justice Pelletier strayed away from civil law, instead relying on the common law principles outlined by the Supreme Court of Canada in Honda Canada inc. v. Keays,… Lire la suite
Class actions and the golden rule of proportionality
By Ashley KandestinDeGrandpré Chait S.E.N.C.R.L/LLP In class actions, before a motion to institute proceedings is filed, the claim must first be certified by a judge of the Superior Court. Article 1003 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CCP) establishes the four criteria that must be met in order for a group to get the green light. The Superior Court recently refused certification of an action on behalf of consumers alleging an industry-wide practice amongst fuel retailers of dispensing less fuel than what they indicate on the pump screen. Finding no error in the first instance judge’s application of the a criteria, the Court of Appeal, in Lorrain c. Petro Canada, 2013 QCCA 332, upheld the decision and dismissed the group’s appeal. In this judgment, the Court of Appeal writes that the underlying philosophies of the CCP, namely those of good faith and proportionality set forth in articles 4.1 and 4.2… Lire la suite
A Quebec judge is to decline jurisdiction in an international litigation only in exceptional circumstances
By Ashley KandestinDeGrandpré Chait S.E.N.C.R.L/LLP The forum non conveniens doctrine dictates that a court should decline jurisdiction in international matters in the event that a foreign authority is better suited to preside over a litigation. This theory was borrowed from the common law, its Quebec incarnation being article 3135 of the Civil Code of Quebec (“CCQ”).When analyzed alongside article 3148 CCQ, the disposition that grants Quebec authorities the jurisdiction to hear international litigations, the application of forum non conveniens becomes uncertain. Which principle prevails? In other words, should a Quebec judge decline jurisdiction if the court of another jurisdiction is more competent to hear the matter, even when that judge’s jurisdiction has already been recognized by article 3148 CCQ? This question was recently answered by the Quebec Court of Appeal in Stormbreaker Marketing and Productions Inc. c. Weinstock, 2013 QCCA 269. At first instance, Justice Wilbrod Claude Décarie granted the… Lire la suite
